Comments on: Russia and Ukraine’s Australian proxy war https://www.policyforum.net/russia-and-ukraines-australian-proxy-war/ The APPS Policy Forum a public policy website devoted to Asia and the Pacific. Fri, 23 Nov 2018 00:50:37 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.1.7 By: Jon Richardson https://www.policyforum.net/russia-and-ukraines-australian-proxy-war/#comment-12052 Fri, 23 Nov 2018 00:50:37 +0000 https://www.policyforum.net/?p=28825#comment-12052 Would strongly disagree on two points Elizabeth. Firstly Australia has never had dedicated centres of Soviet or Russian studies. What it did have was separate Russian language departments, and its true in the case of ANU and others some/most of these were merged into departments of modern European language. But political scientists and historians specialising in Russia were all in general departments covering those disciplines. The only place with a slight concentration of Soviet specialists was the Political Science Department in the ANU’s then Research School of Social Sciences, which in the 1980s had three academics, led by the great Harry Rigby, supported by two research assistants, and two postgrad students, of whom I was one. But Soviet/Russian specialists at other universities were lone wolves in their departments.

I’d also disagree with characterisation of the Ukrainian Deputy PM’s talk as presentating the conflict with Russia as a clash of civilisations. Rather she portrayed the root result of the problem as Russia’s disregard for democracy. You might disagree with this but it is a widely held view outside Ukraine that Russia’s actions in Crimea and the Donbas were in large part prompted by the prospect of Ukraine moving closer to the EU with its democratic standards and helping undermining the legitimacy of the Putin regime. As well as appealing to lingering great Russian chauvinism towards Ukraine as a way of papering over the domestic democratic deficit and economic problems. I fail to see why this is an unhelpful framing of the problem and why it should be the job of universities to counter this “narrative” as you suggest.

Otherwise I would agree with the nub of your argument that Australia isn’t as well equipped with Russia-expertise as it was in the Cold War and it would be nice if it could be strengthened again as Russian influence becomes more salient globally. But also worth being aware that our expertise was never that great at a time when Russia’s importance was much higher than today.

]]>